It Is Just A Kids’ Film

How often have you heard “it’s just a kids’ film” as the go-to defence for a lacklustre children’s film? This is not only condescending to kids but is demeaning to film in general. This argument is no justification for the failings of a film. People hold kids’ films to a lower standard than the rest of what is released each year, even though they should be held just as high, if not higher.

I have many problems with this insufficient defence of bad kids’ films for many reasons. The first is that bad kids’ films are no different than bad films for adults. It is usually big-budget animated features that get this defence, from Shrek 3D to Monsters Vs. Aliens. While they may entertain kids for the duration of the picture, these are films that will not last in the kids memories for weeks, let alone for years to come. This is no different from films like Transformers 2; films with no redeeming qualities other than mindless action. Yet because these mindless children’s films are aimed at kids they receive a pass.

Of course kids will enjoy something that we see as lacklustre, however as they are certain to leave no positive or lasting effect on the child, what is the point? Inspiring and challenging a child’s imagination is fundamentally important to developing his or her creativity, and film is the perfect medium to do so.

If you think back on the great children’s films that you viewed as a kid, and the films which came and went, the difference in impact is astonishing. While Shrek did nothing for my creativity, Iron Giant made me want to become a filmmaker. People often say that not every kids’ film can be Pixar-quality, and while this is true to a point, why shouldn’t they strive for that? It is simply laziness on the parts of the filmmakers and the studios which do not attempt for anything of lasting quality. A good film for kids does not have to say anything particularly deep, or make the audience cry like in Up, however it should show some respect to the intended audience and deliver something of lasting value.

It seems that to justify the mediocre schlock which accounts for most films aimed at kids people classify Pixar films as films appropriate for kids but aimed at adults. This is simply untrue, they are films which do not condescend or look down on their audience. They embrace the sense of wonder and enjoyment which kids want and add true heart to the mix. This is why Pixar consistently releases beautiful and inspiring films. Filmmakers like Brad Bird, Hayao Miyazaki and Andrew Stanton keep the bar for children’s films very high, as it should be. This high bar should not be an excuse to give up, or deliver something that will only entertain for the run time.

In many ways the genre of kids’ films should not even exist, as a great film for children is a great film for everyone. It just happens to be appropriate for any age. Children may be a film’s primary audience, yet as we see with any children’s film classic, they work for all ages.

I often find myself looking back on the films from my childhood and feeling sorry for the kids of today who have to sit through Yogi Bear 3D. Knowing that the new Pixar film is just around the corner reminds me that there are still great films for kids released each year. It is simply a matter of not accepting the excuse that “it is just a kids’ film”, and holding these films to the appropriate standard.

This entry was posted in Opinion and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to It Is Just A Kids’ Film

  1. Unfortunately, Pixar’s winning streak is going to end this year with Cars 2 😦

  2. Wayne Marshall says:

    Until parents stop throwing money at any kid’s film that comes out, the trend will continue. Studios know that for every kid’s ticket it sells to Yogi Bear 3D they will make double, triple or more on extra tickets for the rest of the group going.
    I have two daughters and they tend to want to see most of what comes out. They can also sit and enjoy movies like “City Lights” “Unbreakable” and “Gone With The Wind”.
    Our rule now is that we will go to the theater and see something that we ALL really want to see and anything else can be caught later on Bluray or cable. Sometimes their grandparents take them to the movies and they see some of the schlock that comes out but half the time they hear about the movie and never choose to see it when it’s available at home after all.

  3. Wayne Marshall says:

    Oh, and I somewhat agree with Boardwalk Cinema. It will make money, but not the repeat money it made from parents returning with their kids like other Pixar movies have in the past.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s